Landed / Guides
How to check if your wholesaler is overcharging you on generics
You don't need a consultant to start this. You need about 90 days of invoice lines, the public NADAC file and a careful afternoon. Here is the method, including the mistakes that make results look worse than they are.
1. Export 90 days of invoice lines
Download an item-level purchase history from your wholesaler's ordering portal, for example McKesson Connect, Cardinal Health Order Express or Cencora's ABC Order. Ask for CSV or Excel, not PDF. You need these columns:
- NDC
- item description
- quantity
- price, per unit or per line
- invoice date
- invoice number, so you can spot duplicate lines.
Nothing about patients is needed. If an export includes patient or prescription fields, remove them before the file goes anywhere.
2. Get the NADAC file for the same period
CMS publishes the full NADAC file every week on Medicaid.gov. Use the rates that were in effect on each invoice date, not just today's file, because generic prices move.
3. Line up the NDCs
NADAC uses 11-digit NDCs (5-4-2). Invoices often show 10-digit NDCs in a 4-4-2, 5-3-2 or 5-4-1 pattern. Add a leading zero to the short segment so they match. For example, 1234-5678-90 becomes 01234-5678-90. If you skip this step, lines simply won't match, and the comparison will look cleaner than it really is.
4. Convert everything to price per unit
NADAC is priced per tablet or capsule (EA), per milliliter (ML) or per gram (GM). Divide what you paid for each package by the number of units in it.
A bottle of 500 tablets at $11.00 is $0.022 per tablet. If NADAC for that generic is $0.015, you paid $0.007 more per tablet, which is $3.50 more on that bottle.
Pack size is where most mistakes happen. A description that says “90s” next to an NDC registered as a 1,000-count bottle is something to fix, not an overcharge.
5. Rank by dollars, not percent
For each line, multiply the per-unit gap by the units you bought. Then add the lines up by drug. A 200% gap on a $3 item matters less than a 12% gap on something you buy every week, so sort by total dollars.
6. Rule out the false alarms
Before you call your rep, check four things:
- Off-invoice credits. Generic source program rebates and year-end credits lower your real cost, but they aren't on the invoice line.
- Returns and credit memos. Negative lines and credits distort totals if you leave them in.
- Shortage and emergency buys. A one-off purchase from a secondary supplier during a shortage isn't a pattern.
- Timing. NADAC runs about two months behind the market, so a recent price drop may not be in it yet.
7. Take specifics to your wholesaler
Take a short list to your rep or buying group:
- the NDC
- what you paid per unit
- the NADAC rate
- the units you buy each month
- the dollars at stake.
Specific lines get a different conversation than “your prices feel high.” Ask whether each item is on your source program, and whether a different pack size or a different NDC in the same generic group would cost less per unit.
Doing this every month
A single store's wholesaler invoices can easily run to thousands of lines a month. Doing it once by hand is worth it. Doing it every month is where most owners stop. Landed runs this comparison automatically: it matches every line by NDC, converts pack sizes, uses the NADAC rate in effect on each invoice date, sets aside credits and returns, and ranks what's left by dollars. It uses purchasing data only.
See it on your own invoices
Send 90 days of wholesaler invoices and get a free line-by-line cost review against NADAC. Purchasing data only, no patient data.